Thu, 25 Jul 2013 23:15:00 GMT | By Rita Jong; The Malaysian Insider

Hindu mother wins legal fight to also decide children’s faith after husband converts them to Islam

Judicial commissioner Lee Swee Seng said that while K. Patmanathan could convert, he did not have the right to deprive the children and their mothers of the freedom of religion.

In a landmark decision, the Ipoh High court today quashed a man’s move to convert his three children to Islam, the latest episode in a combustible issue in Malaysia.

Judicial commissioner Lee Swee Seng said that while K. Patmanathan could convert, he did not have the right to deprive the children and their mothers of the freedom of religion.

He quashed the three certificates in converting the three minors, which were made without their mother M. Indira Gandhi’s knowledge.

Lee made this decision in allowing Patmanathan’s estranged wife, Indira’s judicial review application to quash the certificate issued by the Perak Religious Department.

The state registrar of conversions, the Perak Religious Department director, the state and federal governments, the education ministry and Patmanathan were named as respondents

Lee allowed the application with no order as to cost.

Indira, 38, a kindergarten teacher, filed a judicial review application in 2009.

Patmanathan, 44, had himself converted to Islam on March 2009 and is now known as Muhammad Ridzuan Abdullah.

He then converted his three children on April 2 the same year.

That same month, the Syariah Court granted him custody of his three children, an order which Indira had challenged in the civil courts.

The High Court subsequently granted Indira an interim order for the custody of their children.

She had claimed that Patmanathan had stormed into her house, had used force against her and their children, Tevi Darsiny, Karan Dinish and Prasana Diksa, who were then aged 12, 11 and one, respectively, before leaving with their birth certificates.

Patmanathan then took away their youngest daughter and until now, the police have failed to locate their whereabouts.

In the decision yesterday, Lee said the certificates were null and void as it was unconstitutional because it was given without hearing the mother or children.

“This was unconstitutional because Articles 3, 5 and 11 of the Federal Constitution state that a mother has an equal right to raise her children to follow her own religion,” he said.

“This decision is no victory for anyone, but we have to learn to live in harmony," said the judicial commissioner.

He also said the conversion was unlawful as the Perak Syariah law states that children must be present to utter the affirmation of faith.

Lee also ruled that the conversion attempt was against the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW).

Indira married Patmanathan in 1993 according to Hindu rites. They have been embroiled in a legal tussle over custody of the children for the past four years.

Today's decision comes after Putrajaya bowed to public pressure and was forced to withdraw the Administration of the religion of Islam (Federal Territories) Bill 2013, at the last Parliament meeting to legalise conversion of minors to Islam unilaterally.

Jul 25, 2013 8:19PM
Kudos to the legal system. At least there's something to brighten our days.
Jul 27, 2013 12:44PM
I think the wife should be given sharing of the custody but cannot reverse back the religion of the children as it is just like returning to darkness (sorry have to be bold and frank as the time for sear****nd waiting for Hindu's final prophet was realized by Prophet Muhammad as the criteria mentioned in Hindu's Scriptures and every muslim has to answer to Allah in hereafter for this action by court if they doesnt object this stand at least in their heart) from the truth as prophet Muhammad had sacrificed so much with his life and soul, physical and mental with the infidels during post Jesus Christ period to spread the truth but still non-muslim could not see the truth just because they are too much respecting ancestor's religion and do not try hard to find the truth of purpose of life and the true God. The muslim leaders must protect the religion of the Children at least by letting the children to be religionless until they reach 18 years old so that they can made suffcifient comparison of faith and way of life through their own logical thinking and knowlegde search.
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Scroll upScroll down